The dining room at Santiago's AT NIGHT

The dining room at Santiago’s.

By Shayne Benowitz

Some people enjoy the lazy days of summer, but in Key West, and especially at Fury, we don’t get a break until after Labor Day. September is notorious for being a sleepy month on the island. That’s great for visitors scooping up off-season rates on accommodations and you’ll enjoy our tropical paradise sans the crowds. Some local restaurants close for vacation, but others stay open and offer great specials.

WARNING: Some of these deals are for locals only. Double check with the restaurant if you’re from out of town! Either way, these are some of the hottest spots on the island you won’t want to miss.

50% Off: Grand Café (Duval St & Caroline St)

Cuisine: New American with Caribbean flare

Ambiance: Casual sophistication in the heart of Duval Street

Notable Dishes: Tomato bisque with jumbo lump crabmeat, seared scallops in key lime beurre blanc, grilled bluefin tuna with wasabi aioli

Fury Girl’s Tip: There’s a quiet little bar nestled in the back, perfect for an after dinner cocktail and dessert.

50% Off Monday-Wednesday: Santiago’s (end of Petronia St)

Cuisine: Spanish-style tapas with a New American twist

Ambiance: Island chic with an urbane edge

Notable Dishes: Beef tenderloin with bleu cheese butter; grouper seasoned with fennel, lemon, and coriander; saganaki: haloumi cheese flambéed with brandy; prosciutto and provolone croquettas; sangria

Fury Girl’s Tip: Order 2-3 dishes per person to share. If you’re still hungry, order more! Save room for their delicious bread pudding dessert.

25% Off: Bagatelle (Duval St & Front St)

Cuisine: French Caribbean

Ambiance: Tropical chic at the foot of Duval

Notable Dishes: Mussels in black peppercorn cream, hearts of palm salad, honey fried lobster tale, filet mignon with gorgonzola

Fury Girl’s Tip: Exceptional martini menu. The espresso martini is made with chilled Illy espresso and will perk you up for the rest of the night.

nine one five's tuna dome dish

nine one five’s tuna dome.

20% Off before 8pm: nine one five (Duval St & Olivia St)

Cuisine: East meets West

Ambiance: Modern tropics at the quiet end of Duval

Notable Dishes: Tuna dome: dungeness crab covered in ahi tuna sashimi, Thai style whole snapper, steak frites au poivre

Fury Girl’s Tip: Head upstairs to the sexy and chic point5 wine and tapas bar after dinner.

Shayne Benowitz is a Fury crewmember and freelance writer. For more travel stories and a daily dose of what’s cool around the globe visit her Wanderlust Website at

**Note About This Content:
This Fury page includes content that reflects past events, attractions, or Fury news that is no longer up to date. As you are reading, please be aware that the information presented on this page is not current and should not be attributed as a current fact.

Last Updated 10/29/2021